I don’t normally use this blog for political messages
but this is the most biased piece I have ever written on this blog. For the sake of full disclosure I am a
Conservative Christian Republican. And
to be honest I don’t like Trump as a presidential candidate for a number of
reasons. The most hilarious of his
tirades is probably how he is going to build a wall and make Mexico pay for it.
What is even more hilarious (in a sad sort of way) is that people believe this
could keep America safe or "Make America Great Again!" Walls actually have a poor success rate throughout history. That being said how
about a brief history of border walls!
The Walls of Jericho:
[About 1400 BC] the children of Israel have just
finished wandering the wilderness for forty years and begin their invasion of
the holy land. When they encounter Jericho.
“2 Then the Lord said to Joshua, “See,
I have delivered Jericho into your hands, along with its king and it’s
fighting men. 3 March around the city once with all the armed men. Do
this for six days. 4 Have seven priests carry trumpets of rams’ horns in
front of the ark. On the seventh day, march around the city seven times, with
the priests blowing the trumpets. 5 When you hear them sound a long
blast on the trumpets, have the whole army give a loud shout; then
the wall of the city will collapse and the army will go up, everyone straight
in.” Joshua 6:2-5
Ok! I know someone is crying foul here, “that’s not
history! That’s Bible stuff!” You’re right!
I did say I am a Christian. The debate of the historical validity of the
Bible can wait. (God helped them anyway.)
The Great Wall of China:
From the 3rd century BC to the 17th century AD approximately
2000 years, a little project called the Great Wall of China was being built and
rebuilt! Now that name may seem a little pretentious but here are a few facts
curtesy of Wikipedia, the wall spans over 5,500 miles, about 40 feet thick and
30-40 ft. high. It was designed to keep out invaders, barbarians, bandits, you
name it. In about 1206 AD (when the wall
was a mere 3,100 miles long) Genghis Khan invaded and sacked most of
China. His son Kublai came back finished
the job by establishing the Yuan Dynasty.
[http://www.history.com/topics/great-wall-of-china]
Maginot Line:
Fast forward to the twentieth century after the First
World War the French built a network of forts and tunnels along the Rhine River
all the way to the Italian border. This of course was stop any future
incursions by the Germans. In May 1940,
the German army bypassed the Maginot Line in the famous blitzkrieg taking
France in about a month. To the line’s
credit it would not be taken until June 1940 around the same time as when Paris
fell. [http://www.history.com/topics/world-war-ii/maginot-line]
The Berlin Wall:
In 1961, Germany was split into two countries. East
Germany, which was communist and allied with the Soviet Union. Then there was
West Germany who was allied to the western nations. To stem the flow of emigration from East
Germany to the West, the East German government began building a wall that
literally cut Berlin in half. The wall was called, “Antifascistischer
Schutzwall” meaning anti-fascist wall. Also known as the Berlin Wall. The wall stood for 28 years and to this day
it is seen as a symbol of repression. [http://www.history.com/topics/cold-war/berlin-wall]
“Come here to this gate! Mr. Gorbachev, open this
gate! Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!” – Ronald Reagan (http://millercenter.org/president/reagan/speeches/speech-3415)
The Korean Border:
There is yet one more wall that makes this list. A wall that is a left over an unresolved
conflict, a symbol of a never ending war.
Along the thirty-eighth parallel that separates North and South Korea,
the Korean Demilitarization Zone (DMZ). A border that is 2.5 miles long and is
constantly guarded. As National Geographic stated “anyone trying to cross the
MDL (Military Demarcation Line) would likely be shot.” (http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/features/world/asia/north-korea/dmz-text/1)
Now most people probably have heard of at least one
and probably all of these examples, what the study of history does is take that
knowledge of a few facts and teaches us of building an argument. A wall isn’t going to keep out terrorists or
anyone who really wants to get into the United States. Whenever I hear someone quote Mr. Trump about
how he is going to build a wall on the Mexican border it reminds me just how
much we need to teach history. A wall
won’t keep out terrorists, drugs, or even illegal immigrants. Walls are inept at keeping out invaders,
symbols of tyranny and represent unending war.
I have to say that, bearing in mind the examples that you gave, implying that "walls actually have a poor success rate throughout history" is not entirely substantiated. Walls are physical barriers intended to keep people (and other critters) out or in. The Great Wall of China did eventually fail, but it also held back scores of other previous invaders. The Maginot Line failed as a wall because it was not complete; the lack of end points and gaps made it more of nuisance than an actual physical barrier. The other examples (the Berlin Wall and the Korean Border) worked splendidly for their intended primary and secondary purposes: secondary to keep people out, primary to keep people IN. If their intent was solely political in nature, I would agree that they failed in compelling sympathy toward their respective causes, but as physical barriers they were quite effective.
ReplyDeleteThank you for the response and the insightful rebuttal.
ReplyDelete